The case has exposed serious flaws in the system.
The NEET fiasco further highlights the need for reforms in these institutions.
Creamy Layer Concept and OBC Reservation: The case raises questions about the implementation of these policies.
Economic Weaker Sections (EWS) Reservation: Income certificates issued by Tehsildars have been criticized.
Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe claims can be verified, but EWS, OBC, and disability categories are vulnerable to fraud.
There is confusion regarding whether the candidate's or father's income should be considered.
How to address changes in income over time.
Tehsildars lack the necessary resources and credentials for proper verification.
Lack of Scrutiny and Updates
Despite problems, there have been no attempts to update regulations.
Cases are not thoroughly investigated due to fear of exposing issues.
The culture of requests and favoritism hinders fair assessment.
Way Forward
Use technology to enhance transparency at all stages.
Implement robust verification mechanisms, including for Aadhaar data.
Issue clear instructions on income and disability applicable nationwide.
Establish bodies to provide guidance on these issues.
Use technology to combat fraud and ensure fairness.
Review the inclusion of mental disability in the quota for civil services.
Introduce an aptitude test for civil service exams.
Impose strict penalties on officers and doctors who certify people incorrectly.
Courts should play a role in ensuring fair selection processes.
Emphasize the importance of serving the nation and discourage self-seeking candidates.
Implement necessary reforms to address the identified issues.
COMMENTS